|
Published
by
Vertical, Inc. New York
ISBN 1-932234-18-7 |
Like many foreigners living in
a faraway land, I often scratched my head
trying to figure out the local business
practices during my years living and working
in Japan. Brought up to believe in the
preeminence of the bottom line, I was
confounded by what often appeared to be the
lack of a profit motive at many Japanese shops
and companies.
While the many factories I
visited appeared to be models of efficiency,
everywhere else I looked - offices,
construction sites, hospitals, hotels - seemed
to be filled with a lot of people doing very
little. Worse, the services were often
expensive, inflexible and sometimes shockingly
unfriendly.
I have my own pet theories
about this state of affairs: a workforce
unable or unwilling to think creatively,
excessive government regulations that favor
companies over consumers, and plain old
inertia. A new book, “Saying Yes to
Japan: How Outsiders Are Reviving a Trillion
Dollar Services Market” written by
longtime Japan hands Tim Clark and Carl Kay,
also takes a crack and unlocks the puzzle.
In fact, it is one of the
better and more systematic attempts to explain
how service industries in Japan work - and
don’t work. I knew Clark and Kay during
my Tokyo days. Both are credible commentators
on Japan’s arcane and underdeveloped
service economy because both of them built,
ran and sold successful companies, and
profited handsomely in the process.
With a journalist’s eye
for detail, they show how Japan’s
service industries operate based on hidebound
principles that have calcified over decades.
They provide countless examples of baffling
rules governing everything from loan
collecting to real estate to health care. They
pepper their text with real examples of
consumers who hit regulatory walls, were
ripped off by a rigged system or simply
received sub-par service.
At the same time, they tell
compelling stories of how foreigners,
unshackled by social constraints, spotted
inefficiencies in these industries and turned
them into opportunities by building businesses
that filled real needs. In doing so, Clark and
Kay have created a set of signposts for others
to follow in search of opportunity in Japan.
This is not, however, a how-to
book for would-be millionaires. There are no
instructions, per se. People looking for quick
hints on where to go and whom to speak to will
be left wanting. There is no directory at the
end with addresses, phone numbers and
websites.
But there is enough material
to allow an earnest entrepreneur to read
between the lines. Take the real estate
market. We learn that real estate agents
represent both buyers and sellers.
“That’s a clear conflict of
interest: if an agent knows both the
buyer’s maximum offer and the
seller’s lowest acceptable price, how
can he act in the best interests of
both?” they write.
The answer, of course, is they
can’t. But consumers, of course, are the
last to know.
Yet some foreigners have taken
advantage of this system. Ken Curtis, whom
Clark and Kay call a successful broker of
commercial property, imported the Western
concept of valuing buildings based not on the
land where they sit, but the amount of money
they generate in rent and leases.
Sounds like basic stuff,
right? In Japan, the idea was so novel that,
in the ultimate form of flattery, the Japanese
quickly tried to master the technique.
There are plenty of other
examples: entrepreneurs who introduced
software as a stand-alone and valuable
product, others who found new ways to collect
loans and still others who have made inroads
into Japan’s archaic healthcare system.
The thread running through
these stories, Clark and Kay write, is a
predisposition in Japanese law and practice
towards corporations, not consumers. More
command economy than capitalism, Japan is full
of examples of heavyhanded government
regulators meddling in the “free”
market.
What’s more, Japanese
companies, like Japanese families, tend to
view the world in a set of “in”
and “out” relationships that
determine who gets served first and with the
best care.
“Contrary to the popular
image of outstanding Japanese service, many
Japanese companies tend to focus more on the
needs of uchi, or in-house groups: employees,
affiliates and suppliers - than on
customers,” they conclude. “They
treat customers politely, of course, and deal
attentively with complaints, but this surface
treatment can mask a lack of strategies for
delivering breakthrough levels of value and
customer satisfaction.”
Not surprisingly, given their
backgrounds, they suggest that Japan needs
more entrepreneurs who can think “out of
the box.” This, of course, is not new.
The Japanese themselves made the same plea
during the fleeting internet bubble five years
ago. The drive, however, disappeared once the
economy plunged into recession afterwards.
Still, if the examples in this
book are any guide, Japan is changing. The
cost and hassle of starting companies has
fallen, a growing number of Japanese workers
are willing to take a chance working at a
start up and the government has unraveled some
red tape. The opportunities to jump in have
never been greater.
Ken Belson is a business
writer for the New York Times. This review
first appeared in the Number 1 Shimbun.